We studied Measurement in this week’s Inventor’s Lab.
This is definitely a topic where the kids’ developmental levels and previous knowledge has a big impact on how much they understand and will remember from the lessons. We tried to find activities that were enjoyable for all ages, knowing that there would be these different take-aways at each age level. At the bottom of this post, I will address these developmental concepts, but first, let’s look at what activities we did.
How tall are you? We had laminated photos of each child with holes punched in the bottom of each, and tape on the back of each one. When children arrived, I had them stand with their back to a wall, and measured how high they were by sticking the picture on the wall above their head. I then had them step away and showed them. Then I tied a string to the picture, dropped the ball of string to the floor, and cut where it touched the floor, to see how tall they were. We then hung the pictures on the wall all together, so they could see how they all compared in height to each other (the taller strings show how tall the shortest adult and tallest adult at the class are). We could have done more with these… I thought about using them as a personal yardstick: “How many Sallys tall is the slide? How many Bobbys long is the path?”
We did this unit in the fall. We saved the photos/strings till spring, and in the last week of class hung them up again so kids could see if they had grown during the year.
How big are you? We had the kids lay down on paper, and traced around them. They had the option to decorate their pictures as much as they wanted to, and also had a worksheet where they could measure and write on their drawing: how tall they are, how long is their arm, how long are their legs, how big around is their head, and so on.
How far can you jump? We taped two pieces of canvas to the floor. On one we marked off feet, on the other we marked off decimeters (tenth of a meter/ten centimeters). They could jump and measure how far they jumped on either scale. They could also lay down on them and reach their hands way up for how high they can reach. They could also pace out the length of the canvas by walking from heel to toe, heel to toe. They would see that the canvas that was 6 feet long according to the ruler might be 12 kid-feet long.
How much do you weigh? We had each child weigh themselves. For older kids, they could create a chart to compare their weights.
How much do these objects weigh? We had three scales out, with dominos, plastic teddy bears, and large plastic jungle animals to weigh. Even the youngest could grasp that the more of one kind of items on the scale, the bigger the number for the weight.
In the sensory table, we had oatmeal, and scoops, and two balance scales, so they could see that if they filled them both with the same amount of oatmeal, the weight would balance.
Building a balance scale: We built balance scales. This photo shows an initial test… our final product involved: cutting three holes in a popsicle stick, punching two holes each in two Dixie cups. Tie one cup to one end of the stick, and the other to the other end. Then stick a pencil or dowel through the center hole. (For more ideas on building balance scales, see my post on levers.)
Water table: volume measurement. We put in a number of measuring cups, spoons, and containers, so they could see how many quarter cups make a cup and so on. I would love to have some tall graduated cylinders so they could see how different “one cup” looks depending on what shape of container it’s in.
Play-dough making: Each of the kids made their own play-dough (we used a half of this recipe per child: http://theimaginationtree.com/2012/04/best-ever-no-cook-play-dough-recipe.html) For the older kids, this was an exercise in reading and following a recipe and in precise measurement of volumes. For the middle-size kids, it was a good experience in following our directions and practicing measuring. For the little kids, they helped with measuring where they could and had a great time kneading their doughs.
Time measurement. We didn’t get into this at all, but some ideas we had were: take an Hourglass Timer. Have the child use a stopwatch (or phone app) to test how long it takes for all the sand to run from one side to the other. Does it always take the same amount of time? If you had them test a one-minute timer, then give them one you know takes three minutes to run sand through. Have them turn both over at the same time, and then keep turning the one-minute as it runs out to learn how many minutes the other timer is.
Set a timer for one minute and have them see how many times they can jump (or clap, or whatever) in one minute. Have a stopwatch, and test how long it takes them to make one loop on the path riding a tricycle.
Books: I didn’t find a book I loved for this unit. Here’s what we compared, with the best listed first. (Note: best for my purposes would be an engaging story line, appealing pictures, and a clear explanation of the content… we work with 2.5 to 7-year-olds, so we need a simple book for the little ones and a harder book for the older ones.)
Super Sand Castle Saturday by Murphy. Age 4 or 5 to 7. Three kids are in a sand castle competition to see who can build the tallest castle, the deepest moat, and the longest wall. They measure the castles with their shovels, but the shovels are different lengths, so the one that’s 3 shovels tall is really about the same height as the one that’s 2 other-shovels tall. They measure the moats with spoons, and the walls with feet / paces. All inaccurate measurements. Then judge for competition uses tape measure to measure each. Engaging story (for older kids) and pictures, and illustrates both how to measure and why standardization matters.
Millions to Measure by Schwartz. Talks about history of measurement: how if one person measured how many feet (paces) from one place to another, they might come up with a different answer than someone with bigger or smaller feet. Then talks about standardized measurements. It’s a good book for 6 or 7-year-olds, but just too long and complex for our circle time purposes.
How Tall, How Short, How Far Away? by Adler. Ages 6 to 8. Talks about measurements in ancient Egypt and Rome. Talks about how standardized measures developed, the imperial system, and the metric system. It’s a good discussion of the history of measurement, but over the heads of our kids. (Even if the cover of the book looks like it’s aimed at young kids… )
Mighty Maddie by Murphy. For kindergarten age. Story line talks about Maddie cleaning her room, and noticing that some things are heavy and some things are light. Semi-engaging story, good illustrations. But there wasn’t as much focus on measurement as I wanted. If I was teaching a class just on weight, it would be a better option.
The Long and Short of It by Nathan and McCourt. Compares things to other things. I like the idea, but don’t like the execution, because the items it compares with are too obscure and abstract. Saying an orangutan has fingers as long as hot dogs makes sense. But saying a giant panda’s fingers are shorter than yo-yos is just odd. So is “Could you fit an aardvark’s snout in your lunch box? … a pig’s snout would fit. It’s shorter than your thermos.” And a “chameleon’s tongue is … longer than a fire hydrant.” Who lays a hydrant on its side as a measurement device? Great illustrations, and probably engaging to read, but I just don’t like it.
For Good Measure by Robbins. Best for 8 to 10-year-olds, I think… The pictures are beautiful to adults – not sure whether or not they would appeal to kids. Covers things like miles, furlongs, rods, leagues, acres, sections, fluid ounce, bushel, peck, etc. Great discussion of all the units of measurement, but far beyond our age group.
Pretend Play and Art: Tell the story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears. Talk about what size each bear is. Ask the children to make houses to fit the bears. See video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-HQK1fejXM&list=PL-OlJZ2hunTIq-hmT6wdVGA6XbPxkb-Ge&index=9
Podcast: Sparkle Stories did an story called “Measuring the World” (Episode 205, dated Feb 22, 2017 – you can listen at the link above, or I download it via BeyondPod) that was all about two five year old girls measuring rocks, plants, animals and each other. They learn a lot about measurement, they also learn that some things stay the same every time you measure them vs. others may grow over time, they learn that some things are harder to measure than others. It’s a nice listen for a 30 minute car ride.
More ideas: For lots more ideas on how to practice measuring, go to http://inspirationlaboratories.com/practice-measuring/
Key concepts of measurements:
Toddler level: Things come in different sizes and qualities. We can compare things by saying “this is taller than that” or “this is heavier than that” or “the red car went further than the blue car” or “this is the biggest.” (At this age, they might not be able to grasp “this one’s taller, but that one is wider, but they’re really about the same size overall.” They’ll usually only focus on one dimension.)
To be ready to learn about measurement in the future, toddlers first need to learn how to count. They have to be solidly capable of understanding “there are 5 duplos in the stack” before they have any chance of understanding “that pencil is as tall as 5 duplos.” (Check out measuring with duplos)
Preschool level: We can introduce ways to measure things. Can use rulers and tape measures and scales, and such. But can also use non-standard measurements… like trace the child’s footprint and see how many of their feet tall something is. Note: we’re just playing with these ideas now – they’re not likely to really truly understand yet.
Kindergarten/first grade: We can start talking about all the different ways to measure things. We can also talk about measurement standards and why they exist.
Help them understand that if we want to compare the height/length of something, we need to make sure that one end of each is aligned. (For example, if comparing the lengths of two pencils, we line up the erasers first, then look at how far apart the points are.)
FYI, here are common core standards for measurement for kindergarten:
- Describe measurable attributes of objects, such as length or weight. Describe several measurable attributes of a single object.
- Directly compare two objects with a measurable attribute in common, to see which object has “more of”/”less of” the attribute, and describe the difference. For example, directly compare the heights of two children and describe one child as taller/shorter.
- Classify objects into given categories; count the numbers of objects in each category and sort the categories by count
And for first grade:
- Order three objects by length; compare the lengths of two objects indirectly by using a third object.
- Express the length of an object as a whole number of length units, by laying multiple copies of a shorter object (the length unit) end to end; understand that the length measurement of an object is the number of same-size length units that span it with no gaps or overlaps. Limit to contexts where the object being measured is spanned by a whole number of length units with no gaps or overlaps.
And here’s a more detailed discussion of common core on measurements and children’s understanding of measurements: https://commoncoretools.files.wordpress.com/2012/07/ccss_progression_gm_k5_2012_07_21.pdf
Addendum: in future classes, we might add in a building project to make this Duplo measuring car